Well that was fun to watch.
Despite his 8 vote deficit in the final tally, Rick Santorum won last night’s contest in Iowa. Had Mitt not campaigned as hard as he did in Iowa, this would simply be another case of social conservatives battling it out while the real action got going in New Hampshire, and Mitt’s showing would be stellar. Unfortunately for the Romney camp, they legitimized the caucuses with Mitt’s attention and a massive amount of super-PAC money, and I think they’ll pay the price for that move over the next few news cycles, not by feeding the perception of failure, but by feeding the perception of anemia that has plagued the campaign to this point.
The other winner last night was Jon Huntsman, whose decision to stay out of the Iowa mudfest was probably the best strategic choice of his campaign to date. It’s now clear that Huntsman was the smart one here, and he’ll reap the benefits of keeping himself clean up to this point. Look to Huntsman as the credible challenger to Romney in next week’s New Hampshire contest.
Dumping 3 million dollars in ads to trash Gingrich, the guy who wasn’t even the actual threat, makes Iowa a phyrric victory at best for Mitt. Romney now has to lean hard on New Hampshire to make sure there are no surprises at all (can you say Jon Huntsman?), which gives everybody else the chance to tool around South Carolina, and build enough momentum to carry on and be a real rival to Romney.
I’d be remiss not to mention Ron Paul’s contribution to last night’s madness. We now know that his fabled youth turnout machine is a paper tiger, and that his support came largely from the same petulant fringe activists that always show up to these things. A third place finish in Iowa now relegates Paul to gadfly status, which is where he should be. Eventually we’ll see the 10% of Republicans who are in his camp leave the GOP for good, and the party will be better off for it.
Newt remains ahead in the national RCP average, and within the margin against Mitt in the Gallup tracker, so I think he’s the guy to pull of a few crucial victories as South Carolina and Florida approach. I guess we’ll see how the bones fall over the next few weeks.